Presented by:

Hey everyone,

We’re here, we’re there, CDG is everywhere.

And this week, that included Used Car Week in San Diego.

Click any link above to learn more, or keep reading below…

— CDG

Not everyone wants to broadcast their mistakes.

But two longtime Washington dealers did just that during last week’s San Diego event.

During their “My Biggest Eff Up: Hard Lessons from Real Dealers,” session, they talked in detail about their most memorable screw-ups and what it cost them at the time.

So, here’s what they had to share about growing too fast, pushing people into roles they don’t want, and holding on to poor habits for too long.

Growing too fast can leave dealers short on staff, planning, and capital.

Randy Fletcher started in the auto world at age 13, and ran his Dad’s dealership for 34 years until it sold.

He called it “the number one independent dealership in Washington.”

Fletcher opened his own store, In-N-Out Auto Sales, in 2016, and grew the business for five years before his so-called eff up.

❝

“I took my eye off the ball,” he said.

Randy Fletcher
In-N-Out Auto Sales

His idea was to open a second store in Montana.

“I’m making so much money,” he said. “I’m gonna double my money, and I’m going to retire a little earlier.”

Why it failed:

  • The right staff wasn’t in place, and his teams weren’t together the way they should have been.

  • Getting cars from Montana was also a step he hadn’t thought through.

  • And repairs at the second shop were another blind spot, because he didn’t think through what it would take to get them all done.

“I worked two times as hard and made half the money,” Fletcher said, adding that the store closed after about two years.

Take it from him: “You need to know that you got the right staff, that you got all the right pieces together, if you have the right capital together and everything else before you just take off…,” he said.

A quick word from our partner

Numa just raised a $45M Series C to run the entire dealership. See what that looks like in your store.

More than 1,500 stores already run on Numa, the AI Operating System for dealerships. It answers calls, texts and chats, puts every caller in the right hands, and flags unhappy customers with LiveCSI™ before they leave.

Promoting people who didn’t ask for it can backfire.

For 22 years, J.T. Curry ran a Tacoma, Wash., dealership that did 900 to 1,000 new and used cars a year. He sold it and retired in January.

His biggest mistake? A promotion. Rich was a finance manager Curry describes as great with compliance and clean paperwork. Customers loved him, and his numbers were strong.

❝

“He was a feel-good, great guy, and his numbers were excellent too,” Curry said.

J.T. Curry

Curry moved Rich to desk manager. Rich pushed back, but Curry took that as humility.

“I came to Rich one day because I wanted it for him, and obviously he didn’t want it,” Curry said. About a year later, Rich came to Curry and said he wanted to resign. He stayed, but Curry called that conversation devastating.

“I was making a decision for him without involving him,” Curry said. “It was a big mess up.”

And candidly, he didn’t learn from it right away:

  • About a year ago, he pulled Jordan, a young salesperson, off the line and sent him to F&I school because he thought Jordan deserved a promotion.

  • “I guess that you can’t want something for somebody who doesn’t want it,” Curry said.

  • Fletcher added that top sellers hit individual goals, but they don’t always make the best coaches.

  • “You take that 20-car guy, you put them on the desk, he’s not going to replace those 20 units,” Fletcher said.

Curry agreed and said that kind of promotion costs you “both ways.”

Fletcher said the question he now asks before promoting someone is “Is this guy gonna be a coach?”

The takeaway: Talk to people before promoting them, recognize when their strengths are best used in their current role, and look for people with a coach mentality, not just your top sellers.

Holding on to old habits is keeping dealers from what’s next.

During the session, Fletcher shared that his dad loved print. 

  • As print faded, his dad kept buying ads anyway.

  • “So we were literally to the last day that the Little Nickel printed, which it was us and the marijuana dealers in the paper,” Fletcher said.

  • Following up, moderator Jessi Roberts, executive director of the Washington State Independent Auto Dealers Association, asked Fletcher which new trend made him as hesitant as his dad was to leave print, and he named AI right away.

“When you got a 63-year-old brain like me, it’s really tough to wrap your mind around that…” Fletcher said.

Roberts said modernizing can be scary when you’ve done things the same way for a long time.

❝

“So I think the real challenge isn’t not moving forward, is balancing the old ways with still learning some of that new, as you try to modernize,” she said.

Jessi Roberts
Washington State Independent Auto Dealers Association

Roberts added that people aren’t getting fired because AI took their job, but that “they’re fired and replaced by somebody who knows how to use AI,” Roberts said.

Still: Curry cautions dealers to not use AI just to save on payroll. He said the personal touch matters more now, not less.

“I think now more than ever, you can be successful by being personal and talking, and you’re picking up the phone and talking to somebody,” Curry said.

To review: Don’t stay stuck in the past, but be smart when you do decide to employ modern tools, such as AI.

The bottom line: Every dealer makes mistakes. The important thing is to learn from them.

(The first time, if you can).

Thanks for reading, everyone.
— CDG

Did you enjoy this edition of the Breakdown newsletter?

Let us know:

Login or Subscribe to participate