Presented by:

Hey everyone,

Yesterday wrapped up day one of Used Car Week, happening in San Diego. So… here are some of the sessions we attended, plus the stats and insights most relevant to dealers.

Enjoy!

— CDG

First time reading a CDG Newsletter?

Welcome to the Market Pulse—your cheatsheet to auto retail, built to help dealers price right, stock smart, and stay ahead.

  • 161 miles: The average distance a buyer now lives from the dealership they buy from, up from about 20 miles in the '90s, according to Executive Vice President of the National Digital Titling Clearinghouse (NDTC), powered by CHAMP Titles, Bryan Calloway.

  • At least 80%: The share of buyers Cox Automotive Executive Vice President and Chief Strategy Officer Jonathan Smoke expects to use AI when buying a vehicle within the next 10 years.

  • 2.6 million: The number of certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicles Smoke expects to be sold in 2027, the fastest-growing segment in his forecast.

(Source: Used Car Week / Cox Automotive / CNW Marketing Research / CHAMP / NDTC)

Cox Automotive's Jonathan Smoke is forecasting modest growth in every segment for 2027, while warning that bigger forces are reshaping the decade ahead.

People were pretty eager to hear Cox Automotive Executive Vice President and Chief Strategy Officer Jonathan Smoke's projections for 2027, myself included…

Even better: When he finally shared the forecast (which he kept for the end of his "The five factors that will define the auto industry's next era" session), it turned out every single area of the market is expected to grow in 2027.

  • Used retail is projected to be up 2%, and new up 1%.

  • That isn't huge, BUT it's the first time in about seven years that every segment is pointing in the right direction, which is worth celebrating.

Of those segments, Smoke said CPO is projected to see the strongest growth, with Cox Automotive expecting about 2.6 million sales. He tied the interest in CPO to affordability, but pointed to a ceiling, which is that there are only so many nearly new vehicles available to certify.

Jonathan Smoke, Cox Automotive | Photo: CDG’s Ash Savage

In less exciting news: Smoke said inflation, higher interest rates, and elevated energy prices (especially diesel) will likely keep affordability tight, at least to start the new year.

The big picture he wants people to take away is that 2027 looks a lot like 2026 with a little more on top, which makes it a good year to get ready for the longer-term stuff.

That longer-term stuff is where he spent a lot of his time, looking all the way out to 2035. He used the ABCs…and, D to frame his point.

  • He said A stood for Agentic AI. His stake in the ground is that at least 80% of buyers will have AI help when they buy a vehicle within the next 10 years. (Compared it to the internet, with even faster adoption.)

  • B = Basket of Bad Things. In other words, not one big threat, but several piling on at once due to smarter shoppers, large used retailers taking share, more regulation (he thinks the FTC was just the beginning), Chinese automakers, and fraud, where he pointed out the bad guys have AI too, just with fewer rules for how they use it.

  • C = Cycles. As Smoke put it, auto is a cyclical business, and he said the last five years of tight supply were the exception.

  • And finally, D = Demographics. Baby boomers, roughly 61 to 80 years old, are the wealthiest generation ever, and as Smoke explained, they love buying cars. That’s great for now, but it becomes a gap in the market eventually.

NOTE TO DEALERS:

Smoke said dealers and OEMs have to account for the fact that around 2030, boomer sales volume falls off and will need to be replaced by the generation behind them.

Issue is: The generations behind the boomers love cars less and are more open to alternatives like robotaxis, generally speaking. That means planning for how to appeal to them will likely take a totally different strategy than what worked for boomers.

NDTC’s Bryan Calloway is warning dealers not to become the Blockbuster of auto, with Carvana’s no-repeat process as the one to learn from.

Also on day one, we heard that the average buyer lives 161 miles from the dealership they transact with. That was a stat shared by Bryan Calloway, executive vice president of the National Digital Titling Clearinghouse (NDTC), powered by CHAMP Titles, during his session "AI-Ready or AI-Risky?”

By comparison: He explained that in the '90s, the average buyer lived about 20 miles from the dealership.

That fact was the basis of his argument that dealerships are in a “change or die” period and risk becoming the Blockbuster of auto, with Carvana as the Netflix that puts them out of business.

Bryan Calloway, NDTC and CHAMP Titles | Photo: CDG’s Ash Savage

His POV: Both of his kids recently bought cars from Carvana. It worked for them, and in one instance, they grabbed his son’s car from a Carvana vending machine within 15 minutes of arriving.

  • More impressive than that is that neither of his kids had to repeat any of the steps it took to buy a car while transacting with Carvana. Once a step was done, it was done.

  • And at no point did they have to re-share information or re-explain what they submitted and to whom, and the process never restarted because of a poor handoff in the workflow.

Point being: Sure, Calloway’s kids bought on Carvana. But he was also the first to admit that’s not something every customer will want to do, which is why dealers should be more focused on what they can learn and replicate from a process standpoint.

Here’s his checklist for accomplishing that…

  • Start with people and process, then add AI.

  • Hire for natural talent by testing candidates or using tools like the Predictive Index or DISC, instead of hiring on experience alone.

  • Give your team the problem, not the steps to fix it, so they can figure out how to problem-solve.

  • Keep people in the lane they’re good at instead of spending time or heavily focusing on what they’re not.

  • Have someone on your team search like a shopper by running AI tools so you can see how people might find, or skip, your store.

  • Make it so customers only have to share information once. (Goes back to our earlier point.)

  • And shorten the title wait. He put holding costs on an unsold used vehicle at $50 to $85 a day. More on that in a later article, though.

WHY IT MATTERS:

“This is our problem, collectively, and we need to change what we are doing in this industry,” Calloway said. “It is dealers, lenders, insurers, auction, test providers, associations. It is time for us to be louder, and if you're not involved in your state, you need to be. You need to have a lobbyist who is talking about: ‘How are you modernizing? What are you doing to change the landscape that we are in that is stuck in the 90s, in the 80s?’ This is something we need to change.”

A quick word from our partner

Impel

Sold-out model. Credit worry. A trade-in lead with a VDP link.

Impel AI doesn't reach for a script. It knows the customer, the vehicle, and your store, then answers like your best rep and keeps the deal moving.

Read real dealership conversations across sales, service, financing, and trade-ins, start to finish. No scripts. Just the receipts.

Day one was packed with insights, so here are a few leftover dos and don'ts from Smoke and Calloway.

As usual, take what works for your store and leave the rest.

Do: Know your customer by age.

If your buyers come mostly from one generation, Smoke says to "circle a date for when you're going to lose all those customers."

Do: Ask someone in Europe what Chinese automakers are doing.

Smoke jokingly told the audience to buy the Europeans attending Used Car Week a drink and ask how operations are looking in their markets, and why, because he thinks it’s a preview of what’s coming here.

Do: Keep building relationships in person.

Even though yesterday was day one of the event, Calloway said his experience at the conference has already shown that this is still a relationship business, and that deals don’t get done over Zoom.

He tied this back to the Carvana piece, arguing that dealers shouldn’t lose the people aspect of the business, but that something has to give from a process standpoint.

Don’t: Treat fraud as someone else's issue to handle.

Smoke (in a different session) said fraud is everyone's problem, and that protecting operations could take partnering with direct competitors.

Case in point: In the same panel, Marguerite Watanabe, president of Connections Insights, mentioned that Dealertrack (a Cox Automotive company) and RouteOne are getting together on bust-out fraud.

Smoke’s 2027 forecast is the big headline, but Calloway’s session is the underbelly.

Meaning: 2027 looks a lot like 2026 with a little more on top, but keeping that going takes a change-or-die mindset. Otherwise, the five to 10 years after it are going to be a lot less forgiving.

Did you enjoy this edition of the Daily Dealer newsletter?

Let us know:

Login or Subscribe to participate

Thanks for reading, everyone.
— CDG