SAN DIEGO — In the coming years, the auto industry will make room for robotaxis, autonomous driving, Carvana-like business models, Ubers, Lyfts, and more, but the likelihood of any one of them totally ousting the United States’ dealer body remains low.
That was one of the takeaways shared by Evan Baker, chief risk officer at Capital One Auto, and Betty Jotanovic, president of auto relationships at Santander Consumer USA, in a Used Car Week panel moderated by Marguerite Watanabe, president at Connections Insights.
“In terms of moving to autonomous or moving to rideshare, there's absolutely a place for that in our economy, and there are areas where that works, but there's still a lot of rural areas in America [where] individuals just want to own their own cars. It's part of our culture, [and] it's a sense of freedom,” Santander’s Jotanovic said.
Here’s why they believe this: For one, customers still show up at dealerships. Baker, with Capital One, said Gen Z is visiting them more than the two generations before it, which he admitted doesn’t add up “unless you’ve met a Gen Z person.”
Also in the session, Jotanovic shared that 78% of respondents in Santander’s latest Paths to Prosperity survey still rely on a dealership for the purchase and the financing, a finding that was true even though more people used AI to help do their shopping.
She also pointed out that cars in the U.S. have a more emotional pull than in many other countries, where vehicles are just seen as a means of getting from point A to point B.
“You think about that feeling when you get your driver's license, and you get your car, you know, it's a sense of freedom, and so I still think there will always be a place for consumer ownership of vehicles, even if we start to see shifts in more urban areas moving to rideshare,” Jotanovic said.
More than emotion: Jotanovic highlighted that the U.S. has a special relationship with financing compared to other countries, which just adds to the unlikelihood that Americans will (at least in the next five to 10 years) stop caring about owning a car entirely.
“There are many countries in the world where [if] you don't have money, you don't get a car... There's no such thing as financing,” Jotanovic said. “You just have to put the cash together. And in some places, multiple families will put their money together to get a car.”
The car business moves fast. Stay ahead.
The most important insights from automotive retail, delivered to your inbox daily.
Join 74,000 others now, it's free:
There are likely several reasons for this, but one of the main ones, per Baker, is the U.S. government’s view of car ownership and the fact that support for vehicle ownership runs deep, regardless of who’s in office.
“Regardless of the administration, there's a general understanding that your quality of life improves with access to a car. So while there may be tightened controls, there may be heightened scrutiny and oversight, [the] fundamentals are that [you’re] more likely to have a job, keep a job, make more money… all of this data points to the fact that cars fundamentally better people’s lives in America.”
Speaking of governments: When asked about the latest election results, Jotanovic said, “The American consumer continues to rely on a car for transportation for everyday life. So, I see it as business as usual for us.” Baker shared similar thoughts, saying, “It does matter, but it’s noise.”
Point being… Car ownership is so deeply ingrained in American culture that a jump from where we’ve been as an industry to a fully autonomous pool, with customers who aren’t interested in shopping in person at all, is unlikely.
It’s also unlikely that a single election period will drastically change how dealers or lenders should be doing business. (At least in the United States…)
Instead, both Jotanovic and Baker suggested the more likely reality is one where the economy benefits from diverse mobility, one where regulatory scrutiny could increase or decrease, but ultimately one where dealers are still integral to the car-buying experience for many shoppers.
Still: The stance that dealers aren’t going anywhere isn’t to say dealers can just operate as they please.
Both speakers were also clear that dealers and lenders have a responsibility to “be obsessed” with their customers’ satisfaction and to help them make decisions that are financially fit for their situation.
“We have to just stay down the middle of the fairway, do what we know is right, and just understand what is expected of us and go meet that expectation,” Baker said.
A quick word from our partner
$500K+ a year in revenue share, across every rooftop.
Dealer groups are banking serious revenue share from customers they already have. In The Car plugs right into your sales and service lanes, so your team can quote insurance on every deal without needing a license. Your people get paid on every quote, and it costs your stores nothing.
There's an added bonus: customers who save on insurance before F&I spend about $513 more in the box, on average.











