It's not uncommon for automotive parts directors to start at the counter as teenagers, working their way up and learning every inch of the business.
That’s not Vince McIsaac.
He said he didn’t know much about automotive.
“...Even my own people will make fun of me, that I barely know the difference between a hood and a Fender to this day,” McIsaac joked.
Fresh eyes: McIsaac came into Hawk Auto Group roughly 12 years ago from a background in computer consulting and warehouse operations, with almost no automotive knowledge to speak of.
But rather than treating his other-industry experience as a liability, he leaned into it.
In his words: "There's a big world out there," he told Daily Dealer Live host Sam D'Arc. "A lot of times, we've been stuck inside these four walls."
Which is exactly why he says his outsider’s perspective shapes how he runs his department.
Case in point: When McIsaac arrived, the parts department was largely manual. No scanning, no logistics software, little in the way of material handling infrastructure.
Knowing that, he got to work modernizing it, but not without friction.
As he explained, people who'd been doing things a certain way for years weren't immediately interested in changing.
“Over time, the results spoke for themselves, and so did the culture shift that followed,” McIsaac said.
Between the lines: Once the foundational processes were in place, McIsaac turned his attention to pricing strategy and found a familiar trap waiting for him.
Manufacturer tier structures, he said, essentially incentivize dealers to chase volume at the expense of margin, creating a race to the bottom on wholesale pricing.
For a while, his group followed that playbook. But then they did the math.
"You go from growing your overall business sales-wise to get that back-end money," he said. "And then eventually you realize, ‘Wow, it's not worth it, with giving away the upfront gross.’"
OUTSMART THE CAR MARKET IN 5 MINUTES A WEEK
Get insights trusted by 55,000+ car dealers. Free, fast, and built for automotive leaders.
His argument: Pulling back on aggressive wholesale discounting (and, yes, raising prices in some cases) is, and was at that time, central to protecting gross profit.
He added that when prices do have to go up, he stresses the need for employees to be transparent, informative, and to keep building the relationship, even when the customer uses your expertise to buy cheaper elsewhere.
Alongside pricing discipline: McIsaac zeroed in on receivables and the chronic friction between parts and service, which, in his eyes, are two other overlooked pressure points.
As he sees it, the us-vs.-them dynamic between those two departments is one of the most persistent and costly myths in fixed ops.
That said, when parts and service managers are in sync, or "bro'd up" as he put it, discounting fights disappear, and everyone wins.
"We've worked really hard on making sure there's no friction," McIsaac said.
Bottom line: Parts isn't a commodity business, even when customers treat it like one. And if McIsaac's career is any indication, sometimes the clearest view of that opportunity comes from someone who never learned to look at it any other way.
A quick word from our partner
Auto Hauler Exchange is the only true vehicle logistics marketplace — connecting dealerships directly with 5,500+ vetted carriers nationwide.
No brokers. No hidden margins. Full rate transparency. Live ELD tracking. Secure in-platform payments.
Reduce dwell time. Cut transport costs 15–20%. Lower fraud risk.
Thousands of dealers are already moving cars smarter on AHX.
