As dealerships face growing pressure to speed service turnaround and meet rising customer expectations, transportation reliability is becoming a key operational differentiator, not just a supply chain issue, according to Frank Granieri, chief commercial officer at A. Duie Pyle.
The details: Granieri told CDG News that freight execution failures increasingly have direct consequences for dealership operations, even when inventory is technically available elsewhere in the supply chain.
Poor freight execution can delay repairs, extend vehicle turnaround times, disrupt service appointments, and increase pressure on fixed ops teams to meet customer expectations.
Fragmented transportation networks and excessive handoffs can create communication gaps, inconsistent service, and limited visibility across the automotive supply chain.
“In many cases, dealers are looking for transportation strategies that help keep parts moving outside traditional delivery windows, including overnight unattended delivery models that support faster service turnaround and improved operational efficiency,” Granieri said via email.
Why it matters: Parts availability means little if logistics failures keep components from reaching the service lane on time. For dealers, unreliable freight can directly hurt throughput, technician productivity, customer satisfaction, and fixed ops profitability.
OUTSMART THE CAR MARKET IN 5 MINUTES A WEEK
Get insights trusted by 55,000+ car dealers. Free, fast, and built for automotive leaders.
Zooming in: Dealers also need to account for the hidden costs of unreliable transportation, Granieri said.
Delayed or inconsistent deliveries can lead to technician downtime, rescheduled service appointments, and excess safety stock.
Misaligned transportation can also increase administrative workload and erode customer trust.
“For dealers operating in fast-paced service environments, consistency and predictability are critical,” added Granieri. “A lower freight rate may not deliver long-term value if service disruptions create operational inefficiencies that negatively impact throughput and the customer experience.”
Between the lines: There are several warning signs that a dealer’s freight strategy may be creating unnecessary risk, according to Granieri.
Key red flags include recurring missed delivery windows, limited shipment visibility, inconsistent transit performance, and overreliance on multiple providers that create unnecessary handoffs.
Another warning sign is when dealership teams are forced to operate reactively instead of predictably.
“If service departments are regularly tracking down parts, adjusting repair schedules, or managing inventory uncertainty, it may signal gaps within the current freight strategy,“ Granieri said.
Bottom line: For dealers, logistics partners are increasingly an extension of fixed ops, not just freight providers. More reliable delivery models could help improve parts flow, reduce service disruptions, and strengthen the customer experience.
A quick word from our partner
Flight to quality is accelerating.
Buyer interest is diverging across brands and markets.
Luxury and top-tier import brands continue attracting premium demand, while other franchises face increasing scrutiny from buyers.
Presidio’s latest Q1 2026 Dealership M&A Market Update explores:
The divergence shaping dealership valuations.
Transaction activity.
And acquisition strategy across today’s market.
