The gap between the average transaction price for a 3-year-old used vehicle and the original MSRP hit a record $16,562 in the third quarter, according to data from Edmunds.

Driving the news: Edmunds noted that the average 3-year-old vehicle sold for $32,039 in the third quarter.

  • Those 3-year-old units had an original MSRP of $48,601, pushing the price difference to a record $16,562.

  • The previous record was at the end of 2019, with a difference of $16,252.

  • Between 2022 and 2023, coming out of the pandemic and chip shortage, the average MRSP jumped $3,497, or 7.8%.

“When you take a step back, and you think where we were back in 2022, 2023, 2024 even, and that ramp-up, that aggressive level of how much vehicles were costing and still do cost,” Ivan Drury, director of insights with Edmunds, told CDG News. “We’re still talking about some of the most expensive used cars we’ve ever seen…compared to when the vehicle was new, you’re getting a heavy value proposition…it’s technically the best value it’s ever been.”

Used prices more stable: Just a year ago, the gap between MRSP and average 3-year-old transaction price was $14,037, $2,525 less.

  • The average transaction price only grew $972 in the past year from $31,067.

  • The residual values dropped from 68.9% last year to 65.9%.

“This is the new norm when we look at both new prices and used prices,” Drury said. “OEMs are aware that the vehicles are selling in a quick enough manner and they're not leasing a lot of inventory. So they know there's not going to be this sudden influx of off-lease…Lease rates have been down for many years now.”

The car business moves fast. Stay ahead.

The most important insights from automotive retail, delivered to your inbox daily.

Join 74,000 others now, it's free:

Staying on the lot longer: Edmunds noted that 3-year-old vehicles are taking 43 days to sell on average.

  • That’s the longest that age of vehicle has stayed on the lot for the third quarter in a decade.

  • It’s also a jump of five days from the second quarter.

Jeep Cherokee staying on lot longest: Among the 20 slowest-turning 3-year-old vehicles, the Jeep Cherokee was the slowest at 64 days, with a price of $23,138.

  • That was two days more than the Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD with an average price of $53,420.

  • The Nissan Maxima was the third vehicle at more than 60 days, 61, with a price of $28,187.

  • Notably, the Porsche 911, with a 98.9% residual value and a price of $188,272, was turning in 51 days.

“People see the other competitors in this segment, and they are not going towards Cherokee, whether it be perceived reliability or MPGs,” Drury said. “That's the thing is that MPG, when you look at that lineup of what's been sitting, if you even look at what's been selling quickly, I don't want to say it's been negligible, but it has been relatively minor in comparison to, say, 2008…Yes, there is some upward movement in pricing on some compact cars, and EVs are holding a little more value, but there are still smoking deals on some of these vehicles that are not high on MPGs. I think that's because a lot of consumers, they're truly putting their entire basket of wants and needs together versus singularly focusing on that one aspect.”

Bottom line: As the fourth quarter closes, Drury points out the need for dealers to be disciplined in their vehicle acquisition and pay attention to market trends, especially with the 3-year-old vehicles.

“You really do have to judge on how much you are willing to pay,” Drury said. “Prices are so high overall, and we are heading into that fourth quarter; vehicles will be sitting. So just don't overpay for any trade-in. Or if you're at the auction and you feel like it's kind of suss, then you don't need to go all in on it.”

A quick word from our partner

Turn Automotive
Turn Automotive: Know your exit before you own the trade.

Turn more appraisals into deals, in the showroom or driveway!

Transform your showroom appraisal into a transparent, interactive customer experience.

And with Off-Site Appraisal™, appraise and buy vehicles directly from customers’ driveways. Every transaction includes Turn’s industry-leading warranty.

Turn Automotive helps you retail more vehicles with guaranteed offers. Know your exit before you own the trade, including vehicles outside your retail stocking plan.

Don’t let the trade stand between you and your next sale.