A family with a history in auto retail and motorsports that dates back a century has sold its seven franchise dealerships in Indianapolis to Five Star Automotive Group.

Driving the news: Dreyer & Reinbold sold its seven dealerships, housed in six buildings, along with their real estate in Indianapolis and Greenwood, Indiana. The deal closed Nov. 16.

For context: The stores represent five brands.

  • Dreyer & Reinbold BMW North, Dreyer & Reinbold Infiniti, and Dreyer & Reinbold Mini sold in Indianapolis.

  • In Greenwood, Indiana, sold were Dreyer & Reinbold BMW South, Dreyer & Reinbold Infiniti Greenwood, Dreyer & Reinbold Subaru, and Dreyer & Reinbold Volkswagen.

  • The Subaru and VW stores share a rooftop.

History matters: Dreyer & Reinbold Racing, which is based in Indianapolis and has competed in IndyCar events, including the Indianapolis 500, for more than 25 years, will stay in the family, according to The Presidio Group.

Presidio represented the family in the sale.

  • According to its team site, Dennis Reinbold founded Dreyer & Reinbold Racing in 1999.

  • The family’s racing roots go back to the 1920s with his grandfather, Floyd “Pop” Dreyer, a former factory motorcycle racer who crewed on a Duesenberg in the 1927 Indy 500 and later built Indy 500 cars.

  • Dennis Reinbold died June 13 at age 65, according to his obituary.

What they’re saying: Derek Reinbold, Dennis’ son, said in a release that selling a family business full of so much history was “an important and deeply personal decision, so it was essential to find the right organization to carry these dealerships forward.”

“Five Star is a respected, family-owned organization that shares our commitment to employees, customers, and the communities we serve,” Reinbold said. 

Worth noting: The deal expands Five Star’s existing Indiana footprint, according to the release.

  • Five Star, a family-owned retailer based in Macon, Ga., was founded in 1986 and has more than 30 locations across the South and Midwest, representing 19 brands, Presidio said. 

  • The group entered Indiana in 2021, buying five dealerships in Lafayette and had grown to six stores in Central Indiana before this deal.

  • Wes Pope, vice president and operating partner of Five Star, said the stores strengthen the group’s position in Indianapolis.

“Dreyer & Reinbold has built an exceptional reputation over generations, and we have tremendous respect for what the Reinbold family has created,” Pope said in the release. “These dealerships are an important addition to our Indiana business and significantly strengthen our presence in the Indianapolis market.”

The car business moves fast. Stay ahead.

The most important insights from automotive retail, delivered to your inbox daily.

Join 74,000 others now, it's free:



Strategic note: BMW and Subaru stores are in high demand, and Indianapolis is a strong market, George Karolis, president of The Presidio Group, told CDG News via email.

  • Dealers ranked Subaru No. 4 and BMW No. 6 among the most desirable brands in Presidio’s Midyear 2026 Dealer Direction Survey, according to the release. 

  • And, the stores in this deal drew much buyer interest, Presidio said.

  • Not to mention, Karolis said, Five Star already owns Mercedes-Benz stores in Indianapolis and was looking to grow there.

“This was a perfect fit,” he said.

You can see this deal announcement and many more throughout the year by visiting the CDG Buy/Sell tracker at CDGbuysell.com, presented by The Presidio Group.

A quick word from our partner

Don’t leave your wholesale strategy up to chance.

Take the uncertainty out of digital wholesale with OPENLANE’s in-depth condition reports — captured by experienced inspectors and enhanced by AI.

OPENLANE CRs feature exterior damage detection, engine audio analysis and decoded OBD2 codes.

OPENLANE Predictive Pricing delivers tighter price ranges and predictions up to 90 days into the future.

No lucky breaks needed.

New dealers to OPENLANE can earn up to $2,500 in fee credits.